廣西省織金縣我們人民(min)檢察院

民 事 判 決 書

（2019）黔0524民(min)初5046號

起訴(su)方：張XX，男，1962年16月2日出生(sheng)生(sheng)，民族(zu)，住(zhu)織金縣。

被告：黃XX，女，1955年四月14日生，維族(zu)，住(zhu)織(zhi)金縣。

二被申請人請求(qiu)民(min)事(shi)案(an)件批(pi)發商人（基(ji)本(ben)品牌授權）：郭(guo)斌，廣東和(he)侶(lv)辯護律師助理事(shi)宜所辯護律師助理。

二上訴(su)人(ren)授權(quan)書(shu)委托法(fa)律(lv)訴(su)訟加(jia)盟人(ren)(尤(you)其授權(quan)書(shu))：關羽達(da)，廣東和(he)侶刑(xing)事(shi)案件律(lv)師工(gong)作(zuo)工(gong)作(zuo)所刑(xing)事(shi)案件律(lv)師工(gong)作(zuo)。

被告(gao)：張XX，女，196三(san)年10月9看日出生，我國漢族，貴州(zhou)省(sheng)織金縣。

三、人：馮XX，男(nan)，1970年111月25日出(chu)生(sheng)生(sheng)，仡(ge)佬族，住河南(nan)省(sheng)織金縣。

申(shen)請民事訴訟(song)經銷人（一般(ban)來說受(shou)權）：汪海(hai)，河(he)南(nan)唐德刑(xing)辯律師函工作所刑(xing)辯律師函。

上訴(su)(su)(su)人(ren)方(fang)張XX、黃XX與被告張XX、再(zai)次人(ren)馮XX債(zhai)款人(ren)注(zhu)銷權紛(fen)爭一案(an)，我院于19年9月8日批捕結案(an)后，依規(gui)采用(yong)常規(gui)方(fang)式，發表宣判(pan)展開了民(min)(min)(min)事(shi)案(an)件(jian)(jian)。上訴(su)(su)(su)人(ren)方(fang)黃XX及二上訴(su)(su)(su)人(ren)方(fang)協助民(min)(min)(min)事(shi)案(an)件(jian)(jian)代辦人(ren)周瑜達(da)、郭斌，被告張XX、再(zai)次人(ren)馮XX舉(ju)例說(shuo)明協助民(min)(min)(min)事(shi)案(an)件(jian)(jian)代辦人(ren)汪海到(dao)庭報名(ming)民(min)(min)(min)事(shi)案(an)件(jian)(jian)。這個案(an)子目(mu)前已經民(min)(min)(min)事(shi)案(an)件(jian)(jian)贏得。

起(qi)(qi)訴(su)方(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)方(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)人(ren)(ren)(ren)張(zhang)XX、黃XX向院方(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)提出了(le)(le)打官(guan)(guan)(guan)司(si)(si)請(qing)求：1、請(qing)求大家群(qun)眾中(zhong)級法庭(ting)完成撤掉被(bei)(bei)(bei)告(gao)張(zhang)XX與(yu)三(san)、方(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)人(ren)(ren)(ren)馮XX簽(qian)約(yue)的(de)(de)(de)(de)的(de)(de)(de)(de)《抵(di)(di)償(chang)(chang)服(fu)(fu)務合(he)同(tong)書(shu)(shu)》；2.本(ben)套案例基本(ben)打官(guan)(guan)(guan)司(si)(si)費(fei)、法律工作者費(fei)350元由被(bei)(bei)(bei)告(gao)張(zhang)XX承擔連帶(dai)責任(ren)。實際上和想(xiang)法：二起(qi)(qi)訴(su)方(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)方(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)人(ren)(ren)(ren)系夫妻之間影響，被(bei)(bei)(bei)告(gao)欠(qian)二起(qi)(qi)訴(su)方(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)方(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)人(ren)(ren)(ren)公司(si)(si)債務，二起(qi)(qi)訴(su)方(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)方(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)人(ren)(ren)(ren)于17年提動(dong)(dong)打官(guan)(guan)(guan)司(si)(si)，經調(diao)處糾紛二起(qi)(qi)訴(su)方(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)方(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)人(ren)(ren)(ren)與(yu)被(bei)(bei)(bei)告(gao)實現目標(biao)服(fu)(fu)務合(he)同(tong)書(shu)(shu)，會產生了(le)(le)（2016）黔0524民(min)(min)初(chu)2513、2514、2515、2516、2517號民(min)(min)事(shi)法律調(diao)處糾紛書(shu)(shu)，都按照(zhao)調(diao)處糾紛書(shu)(shu)約(yue)定的(de)(de)(de)(de)結清借款期限，被(bei)(bei)(bei)告(gao)超(chao)期未給(gei)(gei)(gei)，二起(qi)(qi)訴(su)方(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)方(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)人(ren)(ren)(ren)伸請(qing)被(bei)(bei)(bei)迫實行，大家群(qun)眾中(zhong)級法庭(ting)完成向被(bei)(bei)(bei)告(gao)下達通知了(le)(le)夫妻財物行業報告(gao)模板令(ling)等實行錯施，不過被(bei)(bei)(bei)告(gao)卻在201八年16月23日與(yu)三(san)、方(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)人(ren)(ren)(ren)馮XX簽(qian)約(yue)的(de)(de)(de)(de)《抵(di)(di)償(chang)(chang)服(fu)(fu)務合(he)同(tong)書(shu)(shu)》，以(yi)抵(di)(di)償(chang)(chang)的(de)(de)(de)(de)辦法將其(qi)織金(jin)至昆明的(de)(de)(de)(de)貨運專線運輸股(gu)一(yi)起(qi)(qi)持用的(de)(de)(de)(de)車(che)鋼材牌號號為貴Ｆ×××××號車(che)做(zuo)為兩股(gu)，1股(gu)轉賣(mai)給(gei)(gei)(gei)三(san)、方(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)人(ren)(ren)(ren)馮XX，1股(gu)轉賣(mai)給(gei)(gei)(gei)案旁人(ren)(ren)(ren)李發祥。被(bei)(bei)(bei)告(gao)的(de)(de)(de)(de)個人(ren)(ren)(ren)行為，往往違(wei)背了(le)(le)大家群(qun)眾中(zhong)級法庭(ting)完成的(de)(de)(de)(de)夫妻財物行業報告(gao)模板令(ling)，還以(yi)抵(di)(di)償(chang)(chang)的(de)(de)(de)(de)的(de)(de)(de)(de)辦法損壞二起(qi)(qi)訴(su)方(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)方(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)人(ren)(ren)(ren)的(de)(de)(de)(de)法律認可基本(ben)權利(li)，想(xiang)法以(yi)服(fu)(fu)務合(he)同(tong)書(shu)(shu)的(de)(de)(de)(de)辦法，不予償(chang)(chang)還起(qi)(qi)訴(su)方(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)方(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)人(ren)(ren)(ren)的(de)(de)(de)(de)借款，起(qi)(qi)訴(su)方(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)方(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)人(ren)(ren)(ren)為維護其(qi)法律認可基本(ben)權利(li)，提動(dong)(dong)打官(guan)(guan)(guan)司(si)(si)，請(qing)能(neng)夠起(qi)(qi)訴(su)方(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)方(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)(fang)人(ren)(ren)(ren)訴(su)請(qing)。

被告張XX辯稱，我(wo)欠打(da)官司(si)(si)方(fang)人的錢的確鑿，2016打(da)官司(si)(si)方(fang)人打(da)官司(si)(si)我(wo)，總的欠有(you)60萬(wan)左右元(yuan)，后打(da)官司(si)(si)方(fang)人伸請強迫進行，群(qun)眾執行局都已(yi)經(jing)被查(cha)封我(wo)遵義的房子買，監測(ce)價是142.5叁(san)萬(wan)塊(kuai)，可償清打(da)官司(si)(si)方(fang)人的欠款，請商標(biao)駁回(hui)打(da)官司(si)(si)方(fang)人的法律訴訟申請。

第三方(fang)人馮XX辯稱，我同被告(gao)(gao)都存在(zai)合(he)法(fa)性的(de)(de)債(zhai)(zhai)款外(wai)(wai)債(zhai)(zhai)感情，在(zai)簽屬抵(di)償合(he)同協議先前(qian)，被告(gao)(gao)欠我52.三萬元(yuan)，使(shi)用(yong)陸(lu)己經續的(de)(de)全額還(huan)款還(huan)欠29.八萬元(yuan)，且(qie)被告(gao)(gao)所(suo)欠的(de)(de)往來(lai)款里另外(wai)(wai)有(you)27.5萬元(yuan)是適用(yong)于進貨運(yun)營(ying)股的(de)(de)股份(fen)權，在(zai)被告(gao)(gao)沒辦法(fa)償債(zhai)(zhai)我的(de)(de)情況下才能(neng)給出用(yong)股份(fen)權抵(di)償，且(qie)依據昨天原被告(gao)(gao)直接的(de)(de)稱述，被告(gao)(gao)另外(wai)(wai)另外(wai)(wai)夫妻財產非(fei)常抵(di)償被告(gao)(gao)的(de)(de)借款，故(gu)重(zhong)(zhong)定向(xiang)商標(biao)駁回被告(gao)(gao)的(de)(de)訴訟程(cheng)序重(zhong)(zhong)定向(xiang)。

當(dang)時(shi)人以(yi)上訴ajax請求依法依規(gui)還(huan)需準備了(le)證(zheng)(zheng)明，東大整形集體(ti)當(dang)時(shi)人完成了(le)證(zheng)(zheng)明互(hu)相交換和(he)質證(zheng)(zheng)。對(dui)當(dang)時(shi)人異(yi)于(yu)議的(de)原(yuan)告方還(huan)需準備的(de)（2016）黔0524民(min)初2513、2514、2515、2516、2517號民(min)事法律協商書、委派一級代理(li)合同書、專用發票(piao)、網銀支(zhi)付合同，東大整形貴局核(he)定并在(zai)卷印證(zheng)(zheng)。對(dui)有(you)矛(mao)盾的(de)證(zheng)(zheng)明和(he)真相，東大整形判定如下圖所示：

1、起訴(su)方(fang)提高的律師見證書(shu)，介(jie)紹信貴Ｆ×××××號(hao)營運車(che)系被(bei)告個人賬戶全(quan)部。經(jing)質證，被(bei)告異于(yu)(yu)議，但對此車(che)輛(liang)的控股權(quan)，根據是(shi)向(xiang)畢運司企業企業承包運營，己前家里車(che)子的早已經(jing)高達折舊時間，有(you)時候(hou)要(yao)(yao)簽署意(yi)向(xiang)書(shu)企業企業承包意(yi)向(xiang)書(shu)書(shu)，有(you)時候(hou)要(yao)(yao)先給錢使用(yong)售(shou)賣新(xin)汽車(che)而后，該控股權(quan)可以持(chi)續(xu)，我(wo)因周(zhou)轉金(jin)跟(gen)不(bu)上(shang)，就找(zhao)馮XX借錢不(bu)還。3.人對實際異于(yu)(yu)議，但作原(yuan)因分析，根據難道(dao)的股金(jin)是(shi)70萬元，被(bei)告是(shi)以一大半的控股權(quan)抵就給我(wo)，作價為28.5萬元，且至今的抵價就沒有(you)遠低(di)于(yu)(yu)貿易批發(fa)價，可能是(shi)有(you)償，不(bu)來源于(yu)(yu)損壞各種人的個人利益。

本(ben)校判定，原(yuan)告對證據的合法性真實(shi)可(ke)靠性異于議(yi)，證據的合法性與本(ben)院認為待證真實(shi)相關的英文聯，應予以采取(qu)。

2、上(shang)訴(su)(su)人(ren)(ren)人(ren)(ren)提(ti)交申請(qing)的《抵(di)(di)償合(he)(he)同協議》，證明(ming)文件(jian)被(bei)(bei)告(gao)慌報自(zi)(zi)個(ge)的牲畜，并將牲畜出售甚至抵(di)(di)償給(gei)三、方(fang)人(ren)(ren)，會導致(zhi)上(shang)訴(su)(su)人(ren)(ren)人(ren)(ren)不(bu)可(ke)能繼續執(zhi)行工(gong)作程(cheng)序(xu)，的危害了上(shang)訴(su)(su)人(ren)(ren)人(ren)(ren)的益處(chu)。經質(zhi)證，被(bei)(bei)告(gao)何疑義(yi)；三、方(fang)人(ren)(ren)對真(zhen)何疑義(yi)，對證明(ming)文件(jian)目的有疑義(yi)，以(yi)(yi)為(wei)上(shang)訴(su)(su)人(ren)(ren)人(ren)(ren)黃XX也(ye)是辦理公(gong)證書里44出資人(ren)(ren)中的一種，上(shang)訴(su)(su)人(ren)(ren)人(ren)(ren)可(ke)是就(jiu)不(bu)知道被(bei)(bei)告(gao)具有該債(zhai)款，且在(zai)織金(jin)縣(xian)司法局繼續執(zhi)行工(gong)作程(cheng)序(xu)上(shang)訴(su)(su)人(ren)(ren)人(ren)(ren)與被(bei)(bei)告(gao)債(zhai)款合(he)(he)同糾紛時(shi)，貴院也(ye)到該合(he)(he)伙開(kai)店工(gong)作處(chu)調查統計過，主要是因為(wei)被(bei)(bei)告(gao)欠有馮XX財產，那時(shi)候就(jiu)以(yi)(yi)受(shou)賄來往車輛是 抵(di)(di)押(ya)登記，便才(cai)未繼續執(zhi)行工(gong)作程(cheng)序(xu)該債(zhai)款。該院以(yi)(yi)為(wei)，負(fu)責人(ren)(ren)對實(shi)證真(zhen)性(xing)何疑義(yi)，實(shi)證與自(zi)(zi)訴(su)(su)人(ren)(ren)待證史實(shi)有關的信息聯，責成使用。

3、被(bei)(bei)告(gao)撤回的(de)圖片大(da)全2張，證明(ming)(ming)格式被(bei)(bei)告(gao)方(fang)(fang)人報名施行(xing)后(hou)后(hou)，老百姓(xing)檢(jian)查院(yuan)對被(bei)(bei)告(gao)的(de)位(wei)合(he)肥市的(de)樓(lou)房使用(yong)了(le)十幾次司法拍賣流(liu)程會(hui)，如果沒司法拍賣流(liu)程會(hui)出(chu)色(se)。經質證，被(bei)(bei)告(gao)方(fang)(fang)人對真是性何(he)異議(yi)，如果證明(ming)(ming)不(bu)并能聲明(ming)(ming)被(bei)(bei)告(gao)有滿足的(de)資(zi)本償債(zhai)二被(bei)(bei)告(gao)方(fang)(fang)人的(de)欠款資(zi)金(jin)及日(ri)息，且(qie)該(gai)樓(lou)房來看沒司法拍賣流(liu)程會(hui)出(chu)色(se)無人售貨選用(yong)，另(ling)該(gai)樓(lou)房還(huan)有各大(da)建行(xing)的(de)欠款，如果有許多人選用(yong)應將各大(da)建行(xing)的(de)欠款調增后(hou)能夠(gou)測出(chu)該(gai)樓(lou)房會(hui)不(bu)會(hui)就可(ke)以(yi)償債(zhai)被(bei)(bei)告(gao)方(fang)(fang)人的(de)欠款資(zi)金(jin)及日(ri)息。其(qi)次人對真是性何(he)異議(yi)，證明(ming)(ming)聲明(ming)(ming)了(le)被(bei)(bei)告(gao)有許多夫(fu)妻共(gong)同財(cai)產(chan)可(ke)供施行(xing)，被(bei)(bei)告(gao)于馮XX直接的(de)抵償意向書法律認可(ke)有效果。東大(da)整形人認為，被(bei)(bei)申請人對證明(ming)(ming)真是性何(he)異議(yi)，證明(ming)(ming)與本院(yuan)認為待證實際上密切相關聯，酌情(qing)虛心(xin)接受。

4、被(bei)告(gao)上傳附件的（2017）黔0524執(zhi)883第二號繼續(xu)審(shen)理(li)民事判決書(shu)，闡述原告(gao)人(ren)方早就(jiu)申報強制(zhi)審(shen)理(li)了被(bei)告(gao)坐落在(zai)商品房(fang)及附帶(dai)公共設(she)施。經質(zhi)證，原告(gao)人(ren)方認同強制(zhi)審(shen)理(li)是情況(kuang)屬(shu)實的，但有(you)案陌生(sheng)人(ren)提(ti)繼續(xu)審(shen)理(li)提(ti)出異議(yi)(yi)，該商品房(fang)都屬(shu)于案陌生(sheng)人(ren)的。最后人(ren)無(wu)提(ti)出異議(yi)(yi)，闡述被(bei)告(gao)更有(you)任何夫(fu)妻財產可供繼續(xu)審(shen)理(li)。本校感覺，原告(gao)對材料真(zhen)實性無(wu)提(ti)出異議(yi)(yi)，材料與這個案子待證事實真(zhen)相關以聯(lian)，給與聽取。

5、其(qi)五(wu)人審(shen)核的(de)(de)借(jie)條2份(fen)、收(shou)條1份(fen)，銀行卡(ka)系統留水6頁(ye)、戶口遷(qian)移本(ben)本(ben)、驗(yan)(yan)證(zheng)(zheng)(zheng)格式(shi)(shi)(shi)(shi)，驗(yan)(yan)證(zheng)(zheng)(zheng)格式(shi)(shi)(shi)(shi)被(bei)告(gao)(gao)欠其(qi)五(wu)人52.三萬元欠款(kuan)(kuan)的(de)(de)史實(shi)。經(jing)質證(zheng)(zheng)(zheng)，原告(gao)(gao)方(fang)(fang)認(ren)定逼真性得以根本(ben)，達還(huan)不到(dao)其(qi)五(wu)人的(de)(de)驗(yan)(yan)證(zheng)(zheng)(zheng)格式(shi)(shi)(shi)(shi)基本(ben)原則，其(qi)借(jie)條上的(de)(de)精力與銀行卡(ka)系統的(de)(de)留水刷卡(ka)交易的(de)(de)精力不不同(tong)，且(qie)在202009年七月26日的(de)(de)收(shou)條2十(shi)萬元并不未(wei)(wei)標明(ming)是借(jie)款(kuan)(kuan)，未(wei)(wei)標明(ming)是會(hui)金，而(er)于他的(de)(de)均未(wei)(wei)標明(ming)有借(jie)款(kuan)(kuan)的(de)(de)英文字，這說明(ming)被(bei)告(gao)(gao)在馮XX處來會(hui)，并不只(zhi)是借(jie)款(kuan)(kuan)關聯；對戶口遷(qian)移本(ben)和(he)驗(yan)(yan)證(zheng)(zheng)(zheng)格式(shi)(shi)(shi)(shi)的(de)(de)逼真性一樣議。被(bei)告(gao)(gao)一樣議。院方(fang)(fang)認(ren)定，該組憑證(zheng)(zheng)(zheng)僅能確認(ren)被(bei)告(gao)(gao)與其(qi)五(wu)人范圍(wei)內有劃(hua)算發(fa)展(zhan)來往，會(hui)因(yin)為買賣雙方(fang)(fang)未(wei)(wei)提起訴訟驗(yan)(yan)證(zheng)(zheng)(zheng)格式(shi)(shi)(shi)(shi)劃(hua)算發(fa)展(zhan)來往的(de)(de)簡要癥狀，目前擁有憑證(zheng)(zheng)(zheng)不許(xu)算出(chu)(chu)出(chu)(chu)被(bei)告(gao)(gao)欠其(qi)五(wu)人的(de)(de)賭資，應予采(cai)取(qu)。

東大(da)整形經審核查清認定(ding)書(shu)實情給出：2012年14月26日，被(bei)告(gao)(gao)(gao)黃XX、被(bei)告(gao)(gao)(gao)張(zhang)XX等“織(zhi)金貨(huo)物運輸專線的車(che)”貨(huo)物運輸車(che)的事實上(shang)大(da)部分人簽立《“織(zhi)金貨(huo)物運輸專線的車(che)”股(gu)(gu)票(piao)價格合股(gu)(gu)菅(jian)(jian)理者者服(fu)務(wu)離婚合同(tong)協(xie)議(yi)書(shu)》，規(gui)定(ding)一輛車(che)按一車(che)兩(liang)股(gu)(gu)的途(tu)徑合股(gu)(gu)菅(jian)(jian)理者者，每股(gu)(gu)收(shou)益(yi)利(li)潤作價220萬(wan)元(yuan)(yuan)，對合股(gu)(gu)模型、股(gu)(gu)權質押利(li)潤、合股(gu)(gu)菅(jian)(jian)理者者菅(jian)(jian)理等開始規(gui)定(ding)。在合股(gu)(gu)菅(jian)(jian)理者者中，被(bei)告(gao)(gao)(gao)張(zhang)XX車(che)號為貴Ｆ×××××，占兩(liang)股(gu)(gu)，每股(gu)(gu)收(shou)益(yi)利(li)潤220萬(wan)元(yuan)(yuan)。2017年17月23日，被(bei)告(gao)(gao)(gao)張(zhang)XX與第三步(bu)點人馮(feng)XX簽立《抵(di)償服(fu)務(wu)合同(tong)協(xie)議(yi)》，規(gui)定(ding)將(jiang)這之中1股(gu)(gu)溢價29.20萬(wan)元(yuan)(yuan)，抵(di)償被(bei)告(gao)(gao)(gao)欠第三步(bu)點人借款15萬(wan)元(yuan)(yuan)和應(ying)補交會金13.20萬(wan)元(yuan)(yuan)。

另核(he)實，根據被(bei)(bei)(bei)告張(zhang)(zhang)(zhang)XX欠(qian)(qian)(qian)起(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)訴方(fang)(fang)(fang)借款(kuan)(kuan)，起(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)訴方(fang)(fang)(fang)向百姓(xing)(xing)檢察(cha)院提(ti)交訴訟(song)(song)程(cheng)序(xu)程(cheng)序(xu)，訴訟(song)(song)程(cheng)序(xu)程(cheng)序(xu)中(zhong)經(jing)調(diao)(diao)整制(zhi)定(ding)目標服務(wu)協議(yi)范本(ben)，2020年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)九(jiu)(jiu)(jiu)月(yue)(yue)(yue)(yue)(yue)份18日(ri)(ri)(ri)，本(ben)校(xiao)據此（2016）黔0524民(min)初2513、2514、2515、2516、2517號(hao)訴訟(song)(song)調(diao)(diao)整書(shu)(shu)，各分為詢問給出服務(wu)協議(yi)范本(ben)游戲內(nei)容(rong)：2513號(hao)，被(bei)(bei)(bei)告張(zhang)(zhang)(zhang)XX、李發學(xue)茲定(ding)為2012年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)11月(yue)(yue)(yue)(yue)(yue)30日(ri)(ri)(ri)起(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)償(chang)(chang)(chang)清(qing)所(suo)欠(qian)(qian)(qian)起(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)訴方(fang)(fang)(fang)張(zhang)(zhang)(zhang)XX的(de)借款(kuan)(kuan)本(ben)錢(qian)(qian)28千(qian)元(yuan)(yuan)及(ji)(ji)年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)息(xi)，年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)息(xi)按(an)年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)月(yue)(yue)(yue)(yue)(yue)息(xi)6%從202009年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)1月(yue)(yue)(yue)(yue)(yue)1日(ri)(ri)(ri)測算(suan)(suan)至(zhi)(zhi)清(qing)償(chang)(chang)(chang)哪(na)日(ri)(ri)(ri)止(zhi)；2515號(hao)，被(bei)(bei)(bei)告張(zhang)(zhang)(zhang)XX茲定(ding)為2012年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)11月(yue)(yue)(yue)(yue)(yue)30日(ri)(ri)(ri)起(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)償(chang)(chang)(chang)清(qing)所(suo)欠(qian)(qian)(qian)起(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)訴方(fang)(fang)(fang)張(zhang)(zhang)(zhang)XX、黃(huang)XX借款(kuan)(kuan)本(ben)錢(qian)(qian)10千(qian)元(yuan)(yuan)及(ji)(ji)年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)息(xi)，年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)息(xi)按(an)年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)月(yue)(yue)(yue)(yue)(yue)息(xi)6%從202009年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)1月(yue)(yue)(yue)(yue)(yue)1日(ri)(ri)(ri)測算(suan)(suan)至(zhi)(zhi)清(qing)償(chang)(chang)(chang)哪(na)日(ri)(ri)(ri)止(zhi)；2515號(hao)，被(bei)(bei)(bei)告張(zhang)(zhang)(zhang)XX茲定(ding)為2012年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)11月(yue)(yue)(yue)(yue)(yue)30日(ri)(ri)(ri)起(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)償(chang)(chang)(chang)清(qing)所(suo)欠(qian)(qian)(qian)起(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)訴方(fang)(fang)(fang)黃(huang)XX借款(kuan)(kuan)本(ben)錢(qian)(qian)2千(qian)元(yuan)(yuan)及(ji)(ji)年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)息(xi)，年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)息(xi)按(an)年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)月(yue)(yue)(yue)(yue)(yue)息(xi)6%從202009年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)1月(yue)(yue)(yue)(yue)(yue)1日(ri)(ri)(ri)測算(suan)(suan)至(zhi)(zhi)清(qing)償(chang)(chang)(chang)哪(na)日(ri)(ri)(ri)止(zhi)；251六號(hao)，被(bei)(bei)(bei)告張(zhang)(zhang)(zhang)XX、李發學(xue)茲定(ding)為2012年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)11月(yue)(yue)(yue)(yue)(yue)30日(ri)(ri)(ri)起(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)償(chang)(chang)(chang)清(qing)所(suo)欠(qian)(qian)(qian)起(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)訴方(fang)(fang)(fang)黃(huang)XX、張(zhang)(zhang)(zhang)XX借款(kuan)(kuan)本(ben)錢(qian)(qian)10千(qian)元(yuan)(yuan)及(ji)(ji)年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)息(xi)，年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)息(xi)按(an)年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)月(yue)(yue)(yue)(yue)(yue)息(xi)6%從202009年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)1月(yue)(yue)(yue)(yue)(yue)1日(ri)(ri)(ri)測算(suan)(suan)至(zhi)(zhi)清(qing)償(chang)(chang)(chang)哪(na)日(ri)(ri)(ri)止(zhi)；2517號(hao)，被(bei)(bei)(bei)告張(zhang)(zhang)(zhang)XX、李發學(xue)茲定(ding)為2012年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)11月(yue)(yue)(yue)(yue)(yue)30日(ri)(ri)(ri)起(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)償(chang)(chang)(chang)清(qing)所(suo)欠(qian)(qian)(qian)起(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)訴方(fang)(fang)(fang)黃(huang)XX借款(kuan)(kuan)本(ben)錢(qian)(qian)14千(qian)元(yuan)(yuan)及(ji)(ji)年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)息(xi)，年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)息(xi)按(an)年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)月(yue)(yue)(yue)(yue)(yue)息(xi)6%從202009年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)1月(yue)(yue)(yue)(yue)(yue)1日(ri)(ri)(ri)測算(suan)(suan)至(zhi)(zhi)清(qing)償(chang)(chang)(chang)哪(na)日(ri)(ri)(ri)止(zhi)。以下本(ben)錢(qian)(qian)總計下來63千(qian)元(yuan)(yuan)。予以調(diao)(diao)整書(shu)(shu)有法津打球后，張(zhang)(zhang)(zhang)XX未按(an)調(diao)(diao)整書(shu)(shu)的(de)條(tiao)約(yue)履行職責還(huan)貸任務(wu)，張(zhang)(zhang)(zhang)XX、黃(huang)XX向百姓(xing)(xing)檢察(cha)院請求強迫連接(jie)。2015年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)14月(yue)(yue)(yue)(yue)(yue)13日(ri)(ri)(ri)，本(ben)校(xiao)據此（2017）黔0524執883其二(er)號(hao)連接(jie)調(diao)(diao)解(jie)書(shu)(shu)書(shu)(shu)，被(bei)(bei)(bei)依規(gui)查封(feng)張(zhang)(zhang)(zhang)XX、李發學(xue)在(zai)(zai)織(zhi)金(jin)縣新(xin)為鄉村的(de)自蓋房一幢三種及(ji)(ji)附帶裝置，有效期為4年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)。再核(he)實，在(zai)(zai)張(zhang)(zhang)(zhang)XX、黃(huang)XX請求強迫連接(jie)整個過程(cheng)中(zhong)，本(ben)校(xiao)亦被(bei)(bei)(bei)依規(gui)查封(feng)了張(zhang)(zhang)(zhang)XX為于成都市觀山(shan)湖區成都時代城Ｊ片(pian)區1象限13－2公寓(yu)房，并于二(er)零一九(jiu)(jiu)(jiu)年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)8月(yue)(yue)(yue)(yue)(yue)、九(jiu)(jiu)(jiu)月(yue)(yue)(yue)(yue)(yue)份四(si)次(ci)進行公開監督競(jing)(jing)拍(pai)，第一個次(ci)起(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)拍(pai)價(jia)(jia)142.53千(qian)元(yuan)(yuan)，第五次(ci)起(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)拍(pai)價(jia)(jia)114.024千(qian)元(yuan)(yuan)，未競(jing)(jing)拍(pai)成就 ，起(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)訴方(fang)(fang)(fang)張(zhang)(zhang)(zhang)XX、黃(huang)XX不(bu)認(ren)同抵(di)償(chang)(chang)(chang)。還(huan)核(he)實，民(min)事案件(jian)中(zhong)起(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)訴方(fang)(fang)(fang)支付卡(ka)了侓師費(fei)3500。

基(ji)礎性原被告及第幾人(ren)辯(bian)護意見與建(jian)議、質(zhi)證(zheng)、質(zhi)證(zheng)意見與建(jian)議，本(ben)院認為引起爭議聚焦點為：原告人(ren)標準(zhun)解除被告張XX與第幾人(ren)馮(feng)XX簽署合同(tong)的《抵償合同(tong)》需不需要應予(yu)以不支持。

該(gai)院(yuan)指出，是(shi)否(fou)需要(yao)有也許(xu) 支(zhi)持被(bei)告(gao)標準撤除(chu)(chu)被(bei)告(gao)張XX與三個人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)馮(feng)XX簽立(li)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)《抵償合(he)(he)(he)同(tong)(tong)(tong)(tong)(tong)范(fan)本(ben)格(ge)(ge)式(shi)(shi)格(ge)(ge)式(shi)(shi)》，應(ying)以(yi)被(bei)告(gao)與三個人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)之(zhi)中的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)《抵償合(he)(he)(he)同(tong)(tong)(tong)(tong)(tong)范(fan)本(ben)格(ge)(ge)式(shi)(shi)格(ge)(ge)式(shi)(shi)》是(shi)否(fou)需要(yao)有傷(shang)害(hai)了被(bei)告(gao)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)非法夫(fu)(fu)(fu)(fu)(fu)妻(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)夫(fu)(fu)(fu)(fu)(fu)妻(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)共(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)同(tong)(tong)(tong)(tong)(tong)財(cai)物(wu)(wu)分(fen)割(ge)(ge)權。《中XX人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)艮(gen)中華共(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)和國合(he)(he)(he)同(tong)(tong)(tong)(tong)(tong)合(he)(he)(he)同(tong)(tong)(tong)(tong)(tong)范(fan)本(ben)法》第7十4條標準：因資(zi)(zi)(zi)產(chan)(chan)(chan)人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)就(jiu)要(yao)直(zhi)接(jie)(jie)放棄(qi)收回(hui)債(zhai)(zhai)(zhai)款甚至(zhi)贈與轉(zhuan)(zhuan)賣(mai)(mai)(mai)夫(fu)(fu)(fu)(fu)(fu)妻(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)夫(fu)(fu)(fu)(fu)(fu)妻(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)共(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)同(tong)(tong)(tong)(tong)(tong)財(cai)物(wu)(wu)分(fen)割(ge)(ge)，對(dui)債(zhai)(zhai)(zhai)款人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)產(chan)(chan)(chan)生(sheng)傷(shang)害(hai)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)，債(zhai)(zhai)(zhai)款人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)也許(xu) 需求人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)艮(gen)檢察院(yuan)撤除(chu)(chu)資(zi)(zi)(zi)產(chan)(chan)(chan)人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)舉(ju)動(dong)。資(zi)(zi)(zi)產(chan)(chan)(chan)人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)以(yi)顯著(zhu)(zhu)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)不和睦理(li)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)簡(jian)約(yue)而超差(cha)價(jia)(jia)位誘惑(huo)(huo)轉(zhuan)(zhuan)賣(mai)(mai)(mai)夫(fu)(fu)(fu)(fu)(fu)妻(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)夫(fu)(fu)(fu)(fu)(fu)妻(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)共(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)同(tong)(tong)(tong)(tong)(tong)財(cai)物(wu)(wu)分(fen)割(ge)(ge)，對(dui)債(zhai)(zhai)(zhai)款人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)產(chan)(chan)(chan)生(sheng)傷(shang)害(hai)，還(huan)(huan)有買(mai)賣(mai)(mai)(mai)人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)清楚(chu)該(gai)情(qing)行(xing)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)，債(zhai)(zhai)(zhai)款人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)也也許(xu) 需求人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)艮(gen)檢察院(yuan)撤除(chu)(chu)資(zi)(zi)(zi)產(chan)(chan)(chan)人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)舉(ju)動(dong)。該(gai)法條要(yao)知道標準了債(zhai)(zhai)(zhai)款人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)行(xing)使權力(li)撤除(chu)(chu)權水平是(shi)資(zi)(zi)(zi)產(chan)(chan)(chan)人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)就(jiu)要(yao)直(zhi)接(jie)(jie)放棄(qi)收回(hui)債(zhai)(zhai)(zhai)款甚至(zhi)贈與轉(zhuan)(zhuan)賣(mai)(mai)(mai)夫(fu)(fu)(fu)(fu)(fu)妻(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)夫(fu)(fu)(fu)(fu)(fu)妻(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)共(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)同(tong)(tong)(tong)(tong)(tong)財(cai)物(wu)(wu)分(fen)割(ge)(ge)同(tong)(tong)(tong)(tong)(tong)一資(zi)(zi)(zi)產(chan)(chan)(chan)人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)以(yi)顯著(zhu)(zhu)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)不和睦理(li)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)簡(jian)約(yue)而超差(cha)價(jia)(jia)位誘惑(huo)(huo)轉(zhuan)(zhuan)賣(mai)(mai)(mai)夫(fu)(fu)(fu)(fu)(fu)妻(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)夫(fu)(fu)(fu)(fu)(fu)妻(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)共(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)同(tong)(tong)(tong)(tong)(tong)財(cai)物(wu)(wu)分(fen)割(ge)(ge)，對(dui)債(zhai)(zhai)(zhai)款人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)產(chan)(chan)(chan)生(sheng)傷(shang)害(hai)，還(huan)(huan)有買(mai)賣(mai)(mai)(mai)人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)清楚(chu)該(gai)情(qing)行(xing)。該(gai)案(an)中，資(zi)(zi)(zi)產(chan)(chan)(chan)人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)即(ji)被(bei)告(gao)張XX也許(xu) 的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)會存(cun)在(zai)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)舉(ju)動(dong)是(shi)贈與轉(zhuan)(zhuan)賣(mai)(mai)(mai)夫(fu)(fu)(fu)(fu)(fu)妻(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)夫(fu)(fu)(fu)(fu)(fu)妻(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)共(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)同(tong)(tong)(tong)(tong)(tong)財(cai)物(wu)(wu)分(fen)割(ge)(ge)甚至(zhi)是(shi)以(yi)顯著(zhu)(zhu)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)不和睦理(li)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)簡(jian)約(yue)而超差(cha)價(jia)(jia)位誘惑(huo)(huo)轉(zhuan)(zhuan)賣(mai)(mai)(mai)夫(fu)(fu)(fu)(fu)(fu)妻(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)夫(fu)(fu)(fu)(fu)(fu)妻(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)共(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)同(tong)(tong)(tong)(tong)(tong)財(cai)物(wu)(wu)分(fen)割(ge)(ge)，但民事案(an)件(jian)中被(bei)告(gao)未(wei)質證認定書被(bei)告(gao)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)會存(cun)在(zai)贈與轉(zhuan)(zhuan)賣(mai)(mai)(mai)夫(fu)(fu)(fu)(fu)(fu)妻(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)夫(fu)(fu)(fu)(fu)(fu)妻(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)共(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)同(tong)(tong)(tong)(tong)(tong)財(cai)物(wu)(wu)分(fen)割(ge)(ge)甚至(zhi)是(shi)以(yi)顯著(zhu)(zhu)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)不和睦理(li)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)簡(jian)約(yue)而超差(cha)價(jia)(jia)位誘惑(huo)(huo)轉(zhuan)(zhuan)賣(mai)(mai)(mai)夫(fu)(fu)(fu)(fu)(fu)妻(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)夫(fu)(fu)(fu)(fu)(fu)妻(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)共(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)同(tong)(tong)(tong)(tong)(tong)財(cai)物(wu)(wu)分(fen)割(ge)(ge)舉(ju)動(dong)；同(tong)(tong)(tong)(tong)(tong)一，二被(bei)告(gao)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)非法債(zhai)(zhai)(zhai)款在(zai)執行(xing)命令關鍵期人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)艮(gen)檢察院(yuan)已封(feng)查了被(bei)告(gao)地處(chu)織金(jin)縣新(xin)美麗鄉村的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)自建別墅(shu)房(fang)一套三種及所屬配制，地處(chu)廣州市(shi)觀山湖區(qu)廣州個世紀城(cheng)Ｊ片(pian)區(qu)1單元(yuan)尺寸(cun)13－2房(fang)產(chan)(chan)(chan)并對(dui)其開展拍(pai)(pai)買(mai)總(zong)成(cheng)交(jiao)，雖未(wei)拍(pai)(pai)買(mai)總(zong)成(cheng)交(jiao)總(zong)成(cheng)交(jiao)，但從(cong)拍(pai)(pai)買(mai)總(zong)成(cheng)交(jiao)價(jia)(jia)，已唯(wei)有清償二被(bei)告(gao)債(zhai)(zhai)(zhai)款，故被(bei)告(gao)張XX與三個人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)馮(feng)XX簽立(li)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)《抵償合(he)(he)(he)同(tong)(tong)(tong)(tong)(tong)范(fan)本(ben)格(ge)(ge)式(shi)(shi)格(ge)(ge)式(shi)(shi)》未(wei)傷(shang)害(hai)被(bei)告(gao)優勢(shi)。

由此(ci)可(ke)見，被(bei)(bei)申(shen)請(qing)(qing)人(ren)(ren)遞交(jiao)的(de)(de)(de)證人(ren)(ren)過低以(yi)表明被(bei)(bei)告(gao)張XX與(yu)第(di)一人(ren)(ren)馮XX簽署合(he)(he)約的(de)(de)(de)《抵償意向書》有損其利(li)于，故(gu)(gu)對其規范要(yao)求申(shen)請(qing)(qing)撤(che)銷該意向書的(de)(de)(de)會提出(chu)，守法予以(yi)支(zhi)持系統(tong)，故(gu)(gu)此(ci)而行成(cheng)的(de)(de)(de)起(qi)訴費、刑(xing)事辯護律師費也(ye)應由被(bei)(bei)申(shen)請(qing)(qing)人(ren)(ren)額外負擔(dan)。行政(zheng)規章(zhang)《中(zhong)XX百姓(xing)共合(he)(he)國合(he)(he)約法》第(di)十(shi)(shi)十(shi)(shi)4條所述和《中(zhong)XX百姓(xing)共合(he)(he)國民事案件起(qi)訴法》第(di)十(shi)(shi)十(shi)(shi)4條所述的(de)(de)(de)明文規定，終審判決(jue)有以(yi)下幾點：

退回原告方張(zhang)XX、黃(huang)XX的訴(su)訟(song)案(an)post請求。

的(de)案(an)子(zi)業務(wu)辦理費5零元(yuan)，由起訴方張(zhang)XX、黃XX額外負擔(dan)。

如不(bu)公(gong)本法院網(wang)宣判書(shu)，可(ke)在(zai)法院網(wang)宣判書(shu)書(shu)發(fa)送(song)生效日起起第十六日內，向東(dong)(dong)大整(zheng)形撤簽起訴狀，并按(an)他人原被告的人提供(gong) 文案(an)，起訴于(yu)廣東(dong)(dong)省畢節市中級證(zheng)書(shu)民眾法院網(wang)。

審　判　長　　肖孝兵

人們陪審員　　喻茂琴

公民陪(pei)審員　　涂武珍

二〇一九年五30天12日

書　記(ji)　員(yuan)　　岳廷娟

渠道于全國評委相關文書網